Now that summer is here, I turn to loose setting powder to reinforce my makeup like a pro. I’ve been patronizing Laura Mercier Secret Brightening Powder for eons but in some unprecedented twist of fate, it started to make my under eyes look extra cakey and dry. Hence, the hunt for the next best setting powder. Will Cinema Secrets Ultralucent Setting Powder topple down Laura Mercier? scroll down for the scoop!
Cinema Secrets Laura Mercier
Price $22 (0.60 oz) $25 (0.14 oz)
Shade Availability 6 1
Finish Velvety matte Matte-sheen
Cruelty-free Yes Yes
Key ingredients Tapioca starch, mica Talc, silica
What Cinema Secrets says “an oil-free, ultra-fine loose setting powder for a natural-looking matte finish. Keep your makeup in place with this lightweight, oil-absorbing powder that sets your foundation for all-day wear. Enriched with anti-inflammatory agents and antioxidant to fight free radicals, it leaves a smooth, shine-free finish that’s perfect for all skin types”.
What Laura Mercier says “A transparent, weightless powder to set undereye concealer, brighten dark circles, and diminish signs of visible fine lines. Create the appearance of the most naturally perfected skin, while maximizing the wear and coverage of makeup. This transparent white setting powder brightens, lightens, and boosts luminosity. Formulated with light-reflecting micronized pigments, this super-soft weightless powder delivers a soft radiant finish, never settling in fine lines, accentuating shadows, or building up on skin”.
What I say: “In terms of value for money, it’s Cinema Secrets since you’re getting more product for a lesser cost compared to Laura Mercier. While both contains mineral-based ingredients, I like Cinema Secrets better because it uses tapioca starch (environmentally friendly and safe for use) and mica (safer than talc, gives a radiant look). Laura Mercier on the other hand uses talc (good in oil absorption but whether it’s safe or not in cosmetics is debatable) and silica (prevents caking). In terms of overall finish and quality, I prefer Cinema Secrets because it does not make my under eyes desert-dry. It also helps my makeup stay in place all day without depleting the moisture underneath”.
What’s your favorite setting powder?
15 thoughts on “Which Is Better? Cinema Secrets Ultralucent Setting Powder Vs. Laura Mercier Secret Brightening Powder”
I didn't realize that Cinema Secrets made a setting powder but it makes sense. I think I have both talc-based and starch-based powders, and both kinds do well for me. I try to avoid talc but sometimes it does the job and is worth using but I love how you pointed out the pros and cons
It's nice to see this comparison for sure!
The Cinema Secrets powder sounds really nice. They make my HG brush cleaner. I'm glad to see that they have a nice powder too! Thanks for the comparison.
The Cinema Secrets seems like it will last you for years. I haven't been using translucent powder lately even though I have many. My favorites are IT Cosmetics and Purely Cosmetics Diamond powder.
Cinema Secrets is a great and underrated brand!
Several of my MUA friends like Cinema Secrets. You know I am not big on powder but my most recent LOVE is the Scott Barnes pressed powder, to die for and perfect for the finish touch on a LOTD makeup.
I have and love Laura Mercier, but didn't know about Cinema Secrets. Will have to try it out – it sounds healthier, and cost-effective is always a good thing.
I really need to try this powder. You had me at "better than Laura Mercier!"
I can't believe that it beat Laura Mercier!!!!!! That's amazing, and it's incredible that it is not only better, but more affordable! Great find, twinsy!
This sounds like good powder. I wonder how it would stack up to my favorite Nars loose setting powder.
I've heard so many good things about this powder from Cinema Secrets. I appreciate your candid review. Good to know about the ingredients. I'm always up for a safer/healthier option. I also have dry under eyes, so I'd prefer the more moisturizing powder for sure.
Cinema Secrets is a brand I haven't used since back in my Makeup Artist days and they had a setting powder that I loved, I think the same as this, but different packaging. I love to see that other people use them as much.
Wow, never heard of this brand, but that looks like an amazing translucent powder. 🙂
I've been looking for a good translucent powder. I just brought my Nars one back to the store because I couldn't get it out of the pan. I ended up buying one by Clinique but I am very curious about these two.
You know… I haven't ever tried Cinema Secrets but always wanted to!